By Richard A. Oppel Jr. and Jonah Engel Bromwich
The new commissioner, Darryl De Sousa, 53, inherits a long list of problems that have proved intractable for predecessors, including a near-total lack of trust of the police in many neighborhoods and stunning levels of privation along the city’s most violent streets, even as employment rates have improved and areas like the Inner Harbor have become gleaming tourist destinations.
“We need the numbers to go down faster than they are,” Mayor Catherine Pugh, who has been in office for a year, said at a news conference announcing the change.
For its long-troubled police force, the city has tried an outsider from California via Harvard, who was seen as an agent of change, then a Marylander who was chief of police in a neighboring county. Now, it has changed tack again, appointing in Mr. De Sousa, an insider who has served in the department for 30 years.
Mr. De Sousa will be Baltimore’s ninth police commissioner since 1994.
Mr. De Sousa said he had already begun an initiative to flood the city’s streets with waves of officers from 9 a.m. to midnight. “The priority as of this moment right now is really simple — it’s a really simple priority, and that’s violence reduction,” he said. “Second priority is violence reduction, and third priority is violence reduction at an accelerated pace. That’s the bottom line.”
But residents questioned whether more officers, or another new chief, would be enough. The department has faced allegations of corruption and is operating under federal oversight because of unconstitutional searches and police misconduct aimed at African-Americans. Six members of an elite task force pleaded guilty last year in a scandal that involved stealing guns, money and drugs. And other officers have been accused of shutting off body cameras so they could plant drugs.
In 2015, the city erupted after the death of Freddie Gray from injuries sustained in police custody. In many ways, both the police and predators have come to be viewed as dangers.
“People are not used to having a relationship with the police department where we see them as a helping resource,” said Erricka Bridgeford, an influential community activist and one of the organizers of Baltimore Ceasefire, an anti-violence group. “The challenge is really finding a way to build trust with individuals.” Officers often do not get the time to build trust and relationships, she said.
With about 615,000 residents — almost two-thirds of them black — Baltimore is one of the poorest major cities in the United States. Nearly one in four families live in poverty, far more than the national average. The city has recorded more than 300 homicides in each of the past three years.
By comparison, New York, whose population is more than 10 times greater, recorded 286 murders last year. Los Angeles — another major city that has seen murder totals over the past two decades fall to numbers below Baltimore’s — announced Friday that its police chief, Charlie Beck, would retire after eight years heading the department.
“This idea of ‘throw another thousand cops out there’ I don’t think fixes our crime problem,” said Nick Mosby, who represents West Baltimore in the State Legislature.
Mr. Mosby said that Commissioner De Sousa’s Baltimore roots may give him a leg up in efforts to heal police-community relations. But he fears that will only go so far. Deeper change won’t come until more residents have a real chance at education and economic opportunity, he said.
“The concentration of poverty is the story of Baltimore,” Mr. Mosby said.
In 2012, Anthony Batts, a former chief of the Oakland police with a post at Harvard, became Baltimore’s police commissioner. He was a pro-reform leader who incurred the wrath of the police union, tried to win the ability to fire bad officers more easily, and angered many in the rank and file when he said he had taken over a department mired in a “cycle of scandal, corruption and malfeasance.”
After Mr. Gray’s death and the ensuing unrest, followed by the decision to prosecute six officers in the case, the police presence in many parts of the city diminished, while arrests declined and murders soared. The charges all led to acquittals or were later withdrawn.
Mr. Batts was replaced by Mr. Davis, who had been the police chief in nearby Anne Arundel County. Mr. Davis worked closely with the Justice Department to carry out the changes contained in the federal consent decree. But while community leaders applauded Mr. Davis’s commitment, murders continued apace.
The problem is compounded by the fact that many witnesses remain afraid or unwilling to come forward, viewing officers as interlopers who live elsewhere and care little about what happens in their community.
If, that is, there are even any officers around: The real power on the streets is wielded by pastors and neighborhood churches, and drug dealers and gang leaders, as residents say the police are often nowhere to be seen. Baltimore has almost double the number of officers per capita as the average for cities of its size, but the union has complained that there are not enough assigned to patrol duty.
Police union officials have warned that depleted patrol ranks have rendered the department unable to perform proactive policing and have put it at risk of not being about to protect residents.
In an interview, the union president, Lt. Gene Ryan, embraced Commissioner De Sousa’s plan for more officers on the streets.
“If you’re not familiar with what’s going on there, how can you solve the problems?” Lieutenant Ryan said. “We need boots on the ground. We’ve got to regain their trust. We need to get back to a relationship where we are all family again.”
Commissioner De Sousa, who was until Friday the deputy commissioner of the department’s Patrol Bureau, seemed to embrace that challenge.
“The No. 1 thing you’re going to see is more police officers on the street,” he said.
Katie Zafft, a University of Maryland criminologist, said it was critical that additional officers assigned to the streets not merely drive around but walk the beat, poking their heads into shops and going out of their way to engage residents.
“Just putting more officers on the street isn’t going to solve the problem unless they really make that connection with the community and double down on figuring out what’s going on in those neighborhoods,” Ms. Zafft said.
She added the department must also put as much emphasis on its efforts to cull criminal kingpins who have fueled retaliatory violence.
Richard A. Oppel Jr. and Jonah Engel Bromwich,, NYTimes, “Baltimore Fires Another Police Commissioner, After Record High Murder Rate“, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/19/us/baltimore-police-commissioner-fired.html